This was a very good post in Best of the Web yesterday.
The problem is that Democratic centrists rolled over. Either they yielded their centrist principles in the face of progressive intimidation, or those principles didn’t amount to much to begin with. The most dramatic illustration of this point is the list of moderate Democrats in the Senate: Evan Bayh, Mary Landrieu, Ben Nelson, Bill Nelson, Blanche Lincoln, Jim Webb. Every one of them voted for ObamaCare. Any one of them alone could have put a stop to ObamaCare simply by casting a vote against cloture. Several of them voted “yes” in exchange for special privileges for their states, making quite clear that theirs was not a principled stand.
Had a single Senate Democrat said “no” to ObamaCare–or had a big enough bloc in the House resisted Speaker Nancy Pelosi’s strong-arming–Scott Brown would have been superfluous, and Massachusetts voters might well have stayed true to type and chosen a Democrat.
Expecting progressives to cast aside ideology for the sake of the party is silly. If they did that, they’d be partisans, not ideologues. Democratic centrists, by their behavior over the past year, have shown themselves to be partisans more than ideologues, and that is what made them an ineffective check against the ideological excess that is damaging their party.
The Republican Party is not without its flaws, but the Democratic Party would be much worse without it–and vice versa.
